Bismillah
The news of non-support by the Police Department of the Lady Gaga concert has made shockwaves in the news and social media. The media frenzy started when the FPI (Front Pembela Islam/Islam Liberators Front) threatened to “meet” Ms. Gaga at the airport to turn her back where she came from. The organization accused her of spreading pornography, a devil worshipper, and so on. This led to the question, how will the police react?
Shortly after the news, the Police issued that they will not approve the concert on grounds that it is incompatible with our local culture. They dismissed allegations that they, a Governmental Law Enforcement Body, are under control of some extremist religious groups.
Now much has been made about the FPI’s origins, its violence and run-ins with the law, as well as the police’s “warm” relationship to the group. The Indonesian police’s reputation isn’t one to be proud of, either. But this time I will move away from those political topics. And I’m sure you are all aware of the Lady being discussed.
A few weeks ago in South Korea, Gaga experienced some backlash from its Christian community. The pressure was significant that the government banned children under 18 from attending the show. I was not sure how I stumbled into this news, perhaps some local online outlet reported this. But this phenomenon was not mentioned when discussing Indonesia’s problem with the concert.
What I am getting at is: it is unfair to single out Muslims as the ones fighting against what they deem incompatible with their morals or beliefs.
Personally, I have distanced myself from music. I realized that most pop songs contain nothing more than bad words, bad topics, sexually tendencious lyrics, and all bad stuff wrapped in catchy upbeat tunes. The worst ones are those that doesn’t escape your head after you caught a listen to it. I am also aware of the debates going on about music in the Shariah. I am not to the point that I completely view music as haraam, but I just do not actively seek to listen to it.
The objectionable things that I mentioned about modern music are things that I am sure any reasonable parents would agree as being bad. Something that they would not want their children exposed to before reaching certain maturity levels. And I have not even gotten into talking about the video clips.
It is not just Muslims that are against bad stuff, or maksiat as we say it. Whenever anti pornography rulings are discussed, many accuse the Muslim parties and groups are trying to make everyone wear jilbabs. When Ramadan comes, people complain Muslims are shutting down bars and clubs.
But as one ustadz says, “If wearing bikini is good, surely it will be taught in schools.” Think about it, would you, regardless of religion, want a casino being built near your home, near your market, near your schools? Would you want beer or alcohol store opening freely without regulations?
My point is that Muslims need to try better ways to get their point across. Shutting down discos with white robes, sticks, and shouting takbir would not give sympathy. I am no scholar, but I believe there is no harm in joining together with groups of other faiths or even secular ones in matters of good.
I would love to see Muslim organizations join churches, temples, NGOs in reducing cigarette use. I would love for Muslim youth to work together with youth of other religion to campaign against alcohol use in teenagers. Seek a common ground and work together towards it. Islam is rahmatan lil aalamin. Mercy upon mankind, not just Muslims.